Phone Surveillance 'Reform' Bill Passed by the House is an Obscene Joke
It just wasn't a very good week for phones or for freedom.
Last week's obscene joke of a bill coughed up by a Congress  wheezing with immobilizing congestion morphed an already compromised law about data collection into a green light to spy on everyone.
The bill passed the House last Thursday and is now heading to the Senate where the chances of getting a better bill are pretty slim. The President has endorsed this House bill; after all, it endorses his policies.
Sponsored by Wisconsin Republican Jim Sensenbrenner (the author of the Patriot Act), the ironically named USA Freedom Act's most salient feature is that, contrary to the bluffery about how it's going to rein in the government on phone surveillance, it has now made massive phone data capture legal and public. The NSA and related agencies under this supposed "reform" bill would gain full authority to collect all information from phone companies and, what's more, the bill mandates that the companies hold on to that information (apparently permanently).
The House obviously caved. Not that the first edition of this bill was very good to start with. The government obviously is not going to limit its own power. But the bill as passed by the House is much weaker and, in a "blink if you don't believe it" moment, many Democratic Congressional leaders are actually congratulating themselves. Even John Conyers (D-Mich.), Detroit's traditionally progressive Democrat, supported this bill: "We stand poised to end domestic bulk collection across the board," he said not making clear where he was standing or when domestic bulk collection was going to end. It certainly didn't end with this bill.
On the other hand, a few Congresspeople did express concern, including Sensenbrenner himself, who called the new law "an abuse" of the Patriot Act. One is left wondering what the Wisconsin lawmaker expected from the draconian nightmare he authored.
While that little humorless comedy was playing out, we got another glimpse of how phone surveillance is being used. Wikileaks revealed that the NSA has been collecting phone data on virtually all phones in Afghanistan. This comes on the heels of revelations a few days earlier about such mass phone call collection in the Bahamas, Mexico, Kenya and the Philippines. The punch-line to this gross violation of people's rights is that the bill passed last week doesn't even mention international phone call capture -- that's still left completely unregulated.